Solving a Difficult Design Problem

Greetings all! It’s time for another peek at the Innkeep development journey. 

For this entry, I’d like to show off how we have brought together our narrative and serving gameplay. This was a tricky design problem that required a bit of trial and error. Keep in mind that the mechanics below are still subject to change and refinement over the remainder of development, so your final experience may vary somewhat! 

By the way, did you catch this recent video looking at the cooking system?

First though, we need to have a little refresher on how our narrative mechanics work!

Storylets

As discussed in a previous entry, interactive narrative mechanics are at the core of the Innkeep experience. Each evening you not only serve your guests, but speak with them (and eavesdrop and spy on them too of course!) Conversations with your guests are above all an opportunity for you to learn about their secrets. In particular, you want to know what valuable items might they have with them, and where might they be keeping them! This is going to help you steal from them effectively while they are asleep later on! 

The scrolls shown above the tables have had a bit of a visual upgrade. They’re also a bit longer now!

These conversations are delivered via a “storylet” system, which basically means we have small chunks of narrative (in this case, representing short conversations of a few lines) that are unlocked by different conditions. These conditions can be “states” that represent something qualitative. For example, to select a conversation where we greet a guest, the condition may be that the guest is still a Stranger. When a storylet is complete, this can in turn change guest states, thereby unlocking even more storylets!

The different states of your guests can be checked in your journal.

It’s a great approach when you want the player to have a little bit of a feel for the mechanistic underpinnings of the narrative content. It’s also suitable for more fragmented, interconnected material. You may be familiar with this kind of narrative system from games such as Failbetter’s Fallen London or Sunless Sea. I certainly recommend Emily Short’s blog on the subject if you’d like to learn more about storylets.

The Design Problem

That said, there remained a problem to resolve: the connection with the serving mechanics. This side of the gameplay has a number of different elements. Guests can request specific kinds of drink, as well as ask for their meal for the evening. They also want to be warm (you need to keep that fire going!), and don’t like it if the common room is too dark (candles need lighting and replacing), or their table too cluttered with dirty bowls and plates. But how do we even represent this kind of “guest happiness”, and how should we connect it to our storylet-based narrative mechanics?

Er… no comment.

The Early Concept: Mirth

What we did understand from early on was that “guest happiness” should be tackled at the table-wide level. Our guests arrive and sit in groups, and those groups have conversations over the course of the evening which we can eavesdrop on. Presumably, if a table is not having a good time, they will talk less (or maybe not at all!) Meaning there are less juicy conversations for us to listen to. They might also drink more, which could help unlock narrative content (or just make it easier to steal from).

Mousing over a mirth icon to see an impact breakdown.

An initial attempt at approaching this problem was a “mirth” system, whereby each table had a mood icon in the form of a face, that represented how happy or jolly that table’s group was. Mousing over the icon would reveal a scroll that displayed a breakdown of what was contributing to that mood level. If a table had higher levels of mirth, the idea was that they would have more frequent conversations (and drink more too). Conversely, if mirth got too low, you would loose the ability to speak with those guests entirely until you had cheered them up a bit by looking after them better. 

A grumpy table would refuse to speak with you.

Ultimately though, this initial approach didn’t really work. It kind of linked serving to our narrative content, but only loosely. The different inputs were also combining in ways that were fairly inscrutable, making it hard to gauge the impact of your actions. This was particularly a problem for food serving, where the player can put in a great deal of effort to make nice meals. Why even take the trouble if you can’t really feel the impact of those meals? Similarly, a reward for your effort may be that a table drinks a bit faster, but this also feels a little too intangible. How much will that help me later when I rob them? It’s difficult to get a feel for results that are delayed by so long. 

An experiment with a bar to help better visualize mirth levels.

It was time to go back to the drawing board, and come up with an approach that was suitably transactional, tangible, visually simple, and also thematic. That’s quite a shopping list!

The Rapport System

Our solution was to turn mirth into a kind of resource, now called “rapport” This represents your general standing with a group of guests. Rapport can be “earned” via the basic serving verbs (bringing food and drink, keeping the room warm, well lit and clean). It can then “spent” by eavesdropping on your guests, spying, and via other storylet actions such as asking prying questions. So, instead of a table’s rapport being an end-result of the different actions you have taken over time, it is simply a “current balance” – what you have available to work with for your narrative actions. This balance is represented by a number of pips in the rapport meter (currently, a maxim of four). 


The current visuals of the mirth status icon. I made this creepy mouth a long time ago using my own mouth as a reference, and I’m still trying to find somewhere to shoehorn it in!

This approach makes the impact of serving a lot more tangible. When you bring a drink to a guest that matches their request, the table rapport goes up a point. When they eat a meal, they gradually convert the stars of the meal into rapport points also. The environmental impact of warmth, light and clutter is a little more delayed, but still visually clear. Now and then our guests have reaction icons that show their pleasure (or displeasure) at the environment, and we can see the rapport go up or down as a result. It’s visually simple and it’s always clear what is going on, and why you are gaining or losing points. 

Gaining a point of rapport by bringing a guest the drink they asked for.

This rapport resource makes serving more transactional in a way that is thematic too. If we keep behaving in suspicious ways, lurking around listening and peering at our guests, the rapport level will keep dropping. This represents the guests feeling uncomfortable, or even suspicious, and can be linked to things like shutting down eavesdropping opportunities, or preventing access to certain storylets. On the other hand, looking after your guests in order to gain rapport is now more clearly endowed with a sneaky, instrumental character – you’re looking after them in order to ingratiate yourself and better learn their secrets. 

‘Spending’ a point of rapport to spy on a guest.

While rapport can certainly be replenished, it’s also not a limitless resource. There’s only so much of it to go around in an evening. This further helps underscore the need to be selective about what lines of inquiry you pursue. Do you want to ask that nosy question? Maybe the rapport would be better spent spying on that other guest, or eavesdropping on a conversation. You’ll likely never get to do everything you want, and that pressure encourages you to do your best to serve your guests well, and also to focus your attention on those guests you care the most about! That’s a more interesting space for the player to be in. We have both pressure (which you definitely want in reasonable amounts), and also a need to triage your actions (making ‘interesting decisions’).

There’s more refinement and fine tuning to do as we add narrative content and conduct testing, as well as other wrinkles we can potentially add into the mix. Overall though, we’re very happy with how this system has brought together the narrative and serving sides of the core gameplay loop. I’m excited for more people to get their hands on it in the future, as this is quite a unique blend of mechanics that crosses established genre lines. 

I’ll see you all again in the new year with another update. Hope you have a happy holidays! 

Leave a Reply Text